Stop Treating Customers Like ATMs: A Guide to Sustainable Banking

The postings on this site are my own and do not necessarily represent the postings, strategies or opinions of my employer.

• cloud series that I highly recommend as a pre-read.
• Platformization of Banking - Part 1 - Introduction
• Platformization of Banking - Part 2 - Journeys
• Platformization of Banking - Part 3 - Bank of the Future
• Platformization of Banking - Part 4 - Embedded Finance to uplift TOI
• Platformization of Banking - Part 5 - Relationship Banking
• Stop Treating Customers Like ATMs: A Guide to Sustainable Banking - Part 6

Let's Talk About Elephants in the Banking

Banks often struggle to provide a seamless customer experience, plagued by issues like confusing fees, complex products, and frustrating processes. This article explores common banking pitfalls and offers solutions for a more customer-centric approach."

It's like there are a few elephants roaming around our banks, and no, I'm not talking about those decorative ones near the ATMs. I'm talking about the unspoken truths, the outdated practices, and the occasional product that makes you wonder,

"Who thought this was a good idea?"

This isn't a finger-pointing exercise but rather an opportunity to take a hard look at some common misconceptions surrounding banking products. We're here to debunk myths, challenge the status quo, and hopefully, inspire a more customer-focused strategy.

Customer satisfaction is crucial for any bank's success. Without it, they risk losing customers to competitors who prioritize their needs.

So, let's dive into the world of banking, where we'll explore everything from overdraft charges that could rival a Vegas debt to the mysterious difference between a transfer and a payment. By the end, you'll be armed with the knowledge to make smarter financial decisions and maybe even chuckle a bit along the way.

The Overdraft Illusion: Short-Term Revenue, Long-Term Pain

Ah, the overdraft charge. That magical charge that appears on your statement just when you thought you had everything figured out. An overdraft occurs when you spend more money than you have in your account. Instead of simply declining the transaction, many banks cover it—but at a significant cost. For those unfamiliar with this delightful banking "service," an overdraft occurs when you spend more money than you have in your account. Instead of declining the transaction (which would be the logical and customer-friendly thing to do), the bank graciously covers it for you...for a fee, of course.

And what a fee it is! These fees or interest rates, often around $35 a pop, can quickly add up, especially for customers who are already living paycheck to paycheck. It's a cruel irony: those who can least afford it are the ones who end up paying the most. This service, often marketed as 'overdraft protection,' can quickly become a financial burden, particularly for those living paycheck to paycheck. It's not a loan.

But beyond the immediate financial hit, overdraft fees or interest rates have a far more damaging impact on customer relationships. Data consistently shows a strong correlation between overdraft fees and customer churn. Customers who are frequently hit with these fees are more likely to become dissatisfied with their bank and seek out alternatives. It's a classic case of short-term gain for long-term pain. While overdraft fees might provide a temporary boost to revenue, they erode customer trust and loyalty, ultimately hurting the bottom line.

Impact of Overdraft on Low-Income Individuals:

• Overdraft disproportionately affect low-income individuals and families who are already struggling financially.
• People in lower-income brackets are more likely to overdraft their accounts due to financial instability and smaller cash reserves.
• For those living paycheck to paycheck, a single overdraft charges can trigger a cascade of financial difficulties, making it harder to cover essential expenses like rent, food, and utilities.
• Overdraft charges can trap people in a cycle of debt, as they may need to take out payday loans or use other high-cost borrowing methods to cover the overdraft and subsequent expenses.

So, what's the solution? It's simple: stop relying on overdraft as a revenue stream and start focusing on providing real value to customers. Offer alternatives like low-balance alerts that notify customers when their balance is running low, allowing them to avoid overdrafts altogether, offer term loans. Link checking accounts to savings accounts to provide an automatic safety net. And for those who need access to short-term credit, offer lines of credit with reasonable interest rates and transparent terms. It's time to ditch the "gift that keeps on taking" and embrace a more putting customers first approach.

Penalties as a Profit Center: A Self-Defeating Strategy

The Art of Alienating Customers One Fee One Penalty at a Time

Banks often justify penalty fees as a way to encourage responsible financial behavior. However, their contribution to the bottom line is often minimal compared to the damage they inflict on customer relationships. Is it truly about fostering responsibility, or is it, perhaps, a more cynical exercise in revenue generation disguised as moral rectitude?

From an accounting perspective, the contribution of penalties to the overall bottom line is often surprisingly modest. While they may provide a temporary blip on the quarterly earnings report, they rarely represent a substantial or sustainable source of income. Relying on penalty fees for revenue is an unsustainable strategy that prioritizes short-term gains over long-term customer loyalty. The true cost, however, lies not in the balance sheet, but in the erosion of customer goodwill.

Consider this: a luxury hotel, renowned for its impeccable service, suddenly decides to charge guests a fee for using the concierge. The immediate financial gain would be negligible, yet the damage to the hotel's reputation would be considerable. The same principle applies to banking penalties. They create a sense of resentment and distrust, turning customers into adversaries rather than partners. It's a classic case of prioritizing short-term gains over long-term value, a decidedly unwise move in the long game of customer relationship management.

The philosophical conundrum at the heart of this issue is the very nature of the banking relationship. Should it be purely transactional, a cold exchange of services for fees, or should it be something more? Should we view our customers as mere conduits for revenue extraction, or as individuals with unique financial needs and aspirations? The answer, intuitively, leans towards the latter. A true partnership, built on trust and mutual benefit, is far more likely to generate sustainable value than a relationship defined by punitive measures.

Therefore, the pursuit of penalties as a profit center is not only ethically questionable but also strategically flawed. It's a self-defeating cycle that alienates customers, damages brand loyalty, and ultimately undermines long-term profitability. A far more effective strategy lies in focusing on providing genuine value, building strong relationships, and aligning the bank's success with the financial well-being of its customers. It's time to abandon the archaic practice of profiting from misfortune and embrace a more enlightened, prioritizing customer needs to banking.

Transfers vs. Payments: It's Not Just Semantics, It's About Customer Experience

Let's talk about a topic that keeps bankers up at night (or at least should): the difference between transfers and payments. It's a seemingly simple distinction, yet it has the power to cause widespread confusion and frustration. It's like trying to explain the offside rule in soccer – everyone nods politely, but no one truly understands. In essence, a transfer is when you move money between your own accounts. Think of it as relocating funds from your checking account to your savings account, or perhaps from your "rainy day" fund to your "slightly less rainy day" fund. It's all within the family, so to speak.

A payment, on the other hand, is when you send money to someone else. This could be paying a bill, sending money to a friend for splitting the cost of pizza (because who carries cash anymore?), or perhaps even paying off that "loan" you got from your sibling (we all know how those go). It's an external transaction, a movement of funds from your domain to another. It's not rocket science, but apparently, it's confusing for some.

Let's just call everything 'money movement' and watch the customer confusion skyrocket!

Now, why does this seemingly minor distinction matter? Well, for starters, it affects processing times, fees, and even security protocols. A transfer between your own accounts is usually instantaneous and fee-free, like teleporting money from one dimension to another. A payment, however, might take a few business days to process and could incur fees depending on the method used. It's more like sending a carrier pigeon with a pouch of cash – slower and potentially more costly.

Transfers between your own accounts are typically instantaneous and fee-free, offering a quick and convenient way to manage your funds. Payments to external parties, however, may take 1-3 business days to process and could incur fees depending on the payment method and the terms of your agreement. Security measures also differ, with payments often involving additional protocols to prevent fraud.

While the terms "transfer" and "payment" may seem interchangeable, they have distinct meanings in the banking world. Understanding these differences is crucial for avoiding confusion, errors, and frustration. By communicating clearly and transparently about these terms, banks can build trust with their customers and provide a more seamless and positive banking experience. These are not just move money.

Data-Driven Decisions: Because Gut Feelings Aren't a Strategy

In the hallowed halls of finance, where fortunes are made and lost on the tick of a market, one might expect decisions to be rooted in rigorous analysis and empirical evidence. Yet, surprisingly often, whispers of "gut feelings" and "intuition" echo through the boardroom, influencing product strategies that impact millions of customers. "I just feel like this new platinum card with the exorbitant annual fee will resonate with our younger demographic." "My intuition tells me customers are clamoring for more complex tiered interest rates." Let's rely on our 'gut feelings' to determine product strategy. What could possibly go wrong?

The fundamental flaw in relying on gut feelings is their inherent subjectivity and susceptibility to bias. These "feelings" are often based on limited personal experiences, anecdotal evidence, or simply a desire for a particular outcome. They lack the rigor and objectivity necessary to make sound business decisions. Imagine a doctor diagnosing a patient based on a hunch rather than running tests – the results could be disastrous. The same principle applies to banking. Launching a product based on a gut feeling is like navigating a ship without a compass – you might get lucky, but you're far more likely to end up lost at sea.

Data analytics, on the other hand, provides a clear and unbiased view of customer behavior. It reveals patterns and trends that would be invisible to even the most seasoned executive's "intuition." Data can tell you precisely which features customers are using, which products they're abandoning, and what their true needs and preferences are. For instance, data might reveal that customers are consistently using a particular feature within the mobile app, indicating a strong demand for another features. This insight can then inform the development of new products and services that cater to this need.

By embracing a data-driven approach, banks can transform their product strategies from guesswork to informed decision-making. Data can reveal the true impact of current product strategies, exposing hidden inefficiencies and missed opportunities. It also illuminates the potential benefits of a more customer-centric approach, demonstrating how personalized offers, simplified processes, and valuable services can drive customer engagement, loyalty, and ultimately, profitability.

By embracing data analytics, banks can make informed decisions that better serve their customers and drive sustainable growth.

Conclusion: Time to Break Up with Bad Banking Practices

So, we've journeyed through the sometimes-bizarre world of banking products, shining a light on some practices that, let's just say, haven't aged particularly well. We've seen how overdraft fees, those "convenient" little charges, can quickly morph into a financial black hole for customers, especially those who can least afford it. We've explored the questionable logic of relying on penalties as a profit center, a strategy that seems more intent on alienating customers than generating sustainable revenue. And we've dissected the crucial difference between transfers and payments, a distinction that, despite its simplicity, continues to confound and frustrate. These outdated practices create confusion and frustration for customers, ultimately harming the bank's reputation and bottom line.

We've also touched upon the perils of relying on "gut feelings" to guide product strategy. While intuition can be valuable in certain contexts, it's no match for the objective insights provided by data analytics. In a world awash with data, clinging to hunches is akin to navigating with a map from the 18th century – charmingly antiquated, but utterly ineffective.

Banks must adopt a data-driven approach, leveraging analytics and technology to understand customer needs and develop effective solutions.

Therefore, it's time to face the music: some of our long-held banking practices are simply not sustainable. They erode customer trust, damage brand loyalty, and ultimately hinder long-term profitability. So, let's stop treating our customers like walking ATMs, dispensing cash and charges at our convenience, and start building real, mutually beneficial relationships. Let's break up with these bad banking habits and embrace a future where customer value is not just a buzzword or a simply a fancy UI, but the driving force behind every product, customer journey and service we offer. It's not only the right thing to do; it's also the smart thing to do. Your bottom line (and, more importantly, your customers) will thank you.

‍